top of page

Reputations Mean Nothing

11 minutes ago
2 min read

In southern and Appalachian culture, it is common for the older men to tell us, "Your reputation is everything." Or, "Without your reputation, you're nothing."


My dad used to talk this way. He was a telephone man, and he took extreme pride in doing his work as well as he could. He always went the extra mile. He imagined the men who might come after him to do a repair, opening a box and noticing how much care and tidiness he had given the work.


I admire that about him. I like that he cared enough to go to extra lengths, for his own self-satisfaction, even if others weren't watching.


His reasoning was that his reputation as a worker was on the line. And remember, your reputation is everything.


Here's the problem.


His reputation as a man, a husband, and a father was stellar. To this day, people rave about what an awesome guy my dad is. When I was a kid, my friends used to sing his praises to me non-stop. "Oh, how great it must be to have your dad as your dad!"


But what was the reality in my home?


The reality is that my dad was a deeply unhappy man who was violent and abusive to his family. We always felt like we were walking on eggshells. We all feared him. It was a nightmare upbringing.


What good is a reputation of being a good father, if you're really a horrible father? Which thing has more value: the reputation of being a good father, or actually being a good father?


The answer is pretty clear, isn't it?


In real life, a reputation matters only as much as it reflects the truth. Only unhealthy people put more emphasis on their reputations than they do on realities about themselves.


I would rather have the reputation of being a terrible father, while in reality being a great father, than the other way around any day of the week.


Your reputation is nothing. It is a farce, completely unrelated to anything real, and on its own it carries absolutely no value whatsoever.


The real value is in actually being the thing that we would like to have a good reputation about. Not in people acknowledging it, but in us actually being that, whether or not anybody ever acknowledges it.


It's about living in ways that we ourselves are content with, and that we ourselves can be proud of, whether anybody ever knows it or not. Reputation be damned.


Drawn from The Last Symptom podcast, S4 Ep 2: Reputation. Listen to the full episode: https://LastSymptom.podbean.com/e/s2-ep-4-the-fifth-most-important-episode-reputation/


Brian standing on red sandstone rocks in Sedona, wearing a blue shirt and backpack, with red rock cliffs behind him

Comments


bottom of page